Last Updated on January 9, 2026 by Giorgia Guazzarotti
You know that moment when you catch your reflection and think “why do I look so tired?” Even though you slept fine, your under-eyes tell a different story. The bags, the shadows, that sunken look that makeup can’t quite fix anymore. So you start googling and suddenly you’re drowning in options. Tear trough fillers, lower blepharoplasty, some doctor saying you need both. Everyone’s got an opinion but nobody’s really explaining what’s actually going on with YOUR face. Here’s what matters: fillers and surgery fix completely different problems. Pick the wrong one and you’ve just spent thousands of dollars to still look tired. Or worse, you end up with that weird overfilled look or complications nobody warned you about. So here’s how to make the best choice for your undereye bags:
Struggling to put together a skincare routine that minimises wrinkles, prevents premature aging, and gives your complexion a youthful glow? Download your FREE “Best Anti-Aging Skincare Routine” to get started (it features product recommendations + right application order):
What Are Fillers VS What Is Blepharoplasty
Tear trough fillers are injectable treatments where a doctor injects hyaluronic acid (like Restylane or Juvederm) into the hollow area under your eyes. It’s a non-surgical option, done in-office, takes maybe 20-30 minutes, uses local anesthesia or just numbing cream. You walk in, get poked a few times, walk out. That’s it.
Lower blepharoplasty is actual eyelid surgery where they’re cutting into your face. The surgeon makes an incision below your lash line or inside your lower eyelid, then removes or repositions excess fat and tightens loose skin. It’s a surgical procedure, you’re under sedation or general anesthesia, takes 1-2 hours, and yeah there’s actual recovery involved.
One’s a quick injection you can do on your lunch break. The other’s surgery.
What Fillers Do VS What Surgery Does
What fillers fix: Volume loss and hollowness in the tear trough area. In plain English, they add volume where you’re missing it, filling in that depression between your lower eyelid and upper cheek. This smooths out shadows, makes dark circles less obvious, makes you look more awake and less like you’ve been up for 3 days straight. Good for under-eye hollows, fine lines, mild stuff.
What fillers DON’T fix: Actual fat bags that stick out. Excess skin that’s loose and saggy. Significant puffiness. They can’t remove anything or tighten anything, they only add volume. So if your problem is you’ve got TOO MUCH going on under there, fillers aren’t gonna help. You’re just adding more volume to an already puffy situation.
What surgery fixes: Fat bags from those fat pads that have herniated forward. Excess skin. Severe puffiness. Structural problems where stuff is literally in the wrong place. It removes or repositions the fatty tissue causing the problem and tightens loose skin. It’s addressing the root cause, not just trying to camouflage it.
What surgery doesn’t do: Add volume. If you’re hollow after the surgeon removes fat, you might still need fillers to smooth the transition. Some people end up doing both.
So fillers are for “not enough” and surgery is for “too much.” Get that wrong and you’re screwed.
Filler Results VS Surgery Results
Fillers: You see results immediately, like same day once the initial swelling goes down. That youthful appearance shows up right away which is nice. But here’s the thing nobody mentions upfront – it only lasts 6-18 months, then it’s gone. Your body breaks down the hyaluronic acid and you’re back where you started. You need to keep getting dermal filler injections every year or year and a half to maintain it. It’s a temporary solution, basically you’re signing up for a subscription service. Forever.
Surgery: Takes several weeks to see the final result because of all the swelling. You need patience which is annoying when you just dropped $5k. But once the swelling resolves, the results last 10-20 years or more. It’s long-lasting, essentially a more permanent solution. Natural aging continues obviously, you’re not gonna look 30 forever, but you won’t go back to how you looked before the surgery. Quick gratification vs long-term fix. Depends what you value more.
Filler Recovery VS Surgery Recovery
Filler recovery time: Basically none. Some swelling and bruising for a few days, maybe a week tops. Most people go back to work the same day or next day. You can cover it with makeup if you need to. Minimal disruption to daily activities which is why everyone loves non-surgical treatments.
Surgery recovery time: 7-10 days of obvious swelling and bruising where you look like you got punched. You can probably go back to work after a week but you’ll still look puffy and people will notice. Full results take several weeks as everything settles. It’s real recovery, not the “no downtime” marketing BS. You need to plan for this, take time off, have someone drive you home, the whole thing. So it’s convenience now vs dealing with actual downtime and looking rough for a bit.
Filler Side Effects VS Surgery Risks
FILLERS
- Common filler side effects: Swelling, bruising, redness, tenderness for a few days. Usually manageable, not a big deal, take some Tylenol and you’re fine.
- Less common filler complications: Tyndall effect where your skin looks bluish if they injected too shallow. Prolonged puffiness because hyaluronic acid attracts water so now you look MORE puffy than before you started which is the opposite of what you wanted. Lumps and bumps from bad technique that won’t go away. Asymmetry where one side looks different than the other.
- Serious filler risks: Vascular occlusion – if filler blocks a blood vessel, you can get tissue death or blindness. It’s rare but it happens and when it does it’s catastrophic. This is why you need an oculofacial plastic surgeon who understands facial anatomy and where all the blood vessels are, not some random person at a med spa who took a weekend course. I’m serious about this, don’t cheap out.
SURGERY
- Common surgery side effects: Bruising, swelling, dry eyes, temporary blurry vision, temporary difficulty closing eyes fully which is weird and uncomfortable.
- Less common surgery complications: Infection which needs antibiotics. Scarring though incisions are usually hidden well. Asymmetry. Ectropion where the lower eyelid turns outward and doesn’t sit against the eye properly. Persistent difficulty closing eyes which can become a real problem.
- Serious surgery risks: Vision loss from orbital hemorrhage, bleeding behind the eye. Happens in 1 in 2,000 to 1 in 25,000 cases depending on which study you read. Extremely rare but it’s why you need a qualified facial plastic surgeon who’s done this a thousand times, not someone who dabbles in it.
People with high blood pressure, diabetes, or clotting issues have higher risk with surgery and need extra careful evaluation of their medical history. Both have risks, just different kinds. Fillers seem “safer” because they’re non-surgical but honestly the under-eye area is one of the trickiest spots for injectable fillers because everything’s so delicate there.
Filler Cost VS Surgery Cost
Fillers: $600-$1,500 per treatment depending on where you live and how much product you need. Seems cheaper upfront right? But you’re doing this every 12-18 months. Do the math – over 10 years that’s $6,000-$15,000 or more. And that’s assuming prices don’t go up.
Surgery: $4,000-$6,000 one-time cost. Expensive upfront, hurts the wallet. But it lasts 10-20 years so when you calculate cost per year it’s actually more cost-effective long-term.
Do you want to pay less now and keep paying forever, or pay more once and be done? There’s no right answer, just depends on your situation and how you think about money.
Who Should Get Fillers VS Who Needs Surgery
Get fillers if:
- Your main problem is hollowness and volume loss.
- You have minimal fat bags, mostly just that sunken look.
- Your skin quality is still decent, not super loose.
- You want quick results with no recovery time because you can’t take a week off.
- You’re okay with it being temporary and doing maintenance forever.
- You’re catching this early, maybe in your 30s or 40s before things get really bad.
Get surgery if:
- You have actual fat bags protruding, like real puffiness that sticks out.
- Significant excess skin that’s loose and hanging.
- Severe under-eye bags that no amount of concealer can hide.
- Fillers won’t address your specific problem because it’s structural, you’ve got too much going on not too little.
- You want long-lasting results and you’re done messing around.
- You’re willing to handle recovery time and looking rough for a bit.
- You don’t want to do maintenance appointments forever, you want this fixed.
Consider both if:
- You have a combination of issues – fat bags plus hollowness in other areas.
- Some people get surgery to remove fat and tighten skin, then add fillers to smooth the transition and add volume where needed.
Your surgeon can figure out if you need one or both for the best results but this obviously costs more.
The Bottom Line
Fillers are for volume loss and hollowness in the tear trough area. Quick, temporary, requires maintenance. Surgery is for fat bags and excess skin. Longer recovery, essentially permanent fix. The trick is figuring out what your actual problem is, not what your friend had, not what’s trending on Instagram, not what some influencer got paid to promote. What’s wrong with YOUR under-eye area specifically based on your unique anatomy. Book a consultation with an oculofacial plastic surgeon or double board-certified facial plastic surgeon who specializes in the lower eyelid area. Someone who understands facial anatomy inside and out, can evaluate your situation honestly, and will be straight with you about whether you need fillers, surgery, or both to achieve your aesthetic goals. Because spending money on the wrong treatment just means you’ll be back in a year doing it again, except now you’re more frustrated and more tired-looking than when you started. And nobody wants that.
